Zoologist Sergiy Paramonov and his ‘Chemogenesis—A New Theory of Evolution’ (to the 130th anniversary of his birth)

[Михаленок, Д. Зоолог Сергій Парамонов: Хемогенез — нова теорія еволюції (до 130-річчя від дня народження)]

Dmytro Mikhalenok https://orcid.org/0009-0006-4994-360X

Ukrainian Theriological Society, NAS of Ukraine (Kyiv, Ukraine)

doi: https://doi.org/10.53452/gb2516

Cite as

Mikhalenok, D. 2023. Zoologist Sergiy Paramonov and his ‘Chemogenesis—A New Theory of Evolution’ (to the 130th anniversary of his birth). GEO&BIO, 25: 203-xx. [In Ukrainian, with English summary]

pdf:  pdf

Abstract

The paper present little-known aspects of the scientific activity of the famous expatriate scientist, world-renowned Ukrainian and Australian zoologist, theoretical biologist, and dipteriologist Sergiy Paramonov (1894–1967). The main purpose of this work is to give a detailed presentation to the scientific community on the important but little-known work of the scientist titled ‘Chemogenesis—A New Theory of Evolution’ (theory of chemogenesis). The role of the Kara Dag scientific station (Crimea, Ukraine) in the formation of the so-called points of scientific growth is shown. The scientist had visited the station several times to carry out dipteriologial research; in 1925, he met the famous Russian scientist S. L. Ivanov whose reconsidered research was used in creating the theory of chemogenesis. Paramonov’s theoretical works written in Ukraine in 1934–1943 and devoted to issues of systematics and its novel chemical methods and of species and speciation are briefly considered. Selected postulates of the theory of chemogenesis are described and analysed in short. The scientist drew special attention to the criticism of Darwin’s theory of natural selection and considered it a brilliant achievement of human thought of the 19th century. Noteworthy is that the theory of chemogenesis does not rely on the recognised scientific significance of related areas of knowledge such as geochemistry and biochemistry, but pulls away from them to prove its own correctness. Paramonov had been seeking the truth but did not claim it; he merely tried to show another way to understand the driving forces of evolution, to show that biologists are ‘barking up the wrong tree.’ A logical mistake keeps existing in biology, when the result (morphogenesis) is considered as the cause, and the cause (chemogenesis) as the results. Eliminating natural selection the scientist understood that he had opened a way to recognise various ‘mysterious’ forces. Although Paramonov did not present a respective philosophical basis for his theory, it is still worth mentioning that the solution for the existing antinomy between the mechanistic theory of natural selection and the theory of chemogenesis with certain elements of teleology lies in the combination of mechanistic and teleological explanation of nature. It is important to take the first steps into the unknown, to understand the incomprehensible, or even to admit ignorance than to engage in the simplification of the problem.

Key words: evolution, natural selection, chemogenesis, points of scientific growth, station, irrational element, seeking the truth.

Correspondence to

Dmytro Mikhalenok; Ukrainian Theriological Society, NAS of Ukraine, 15 Bohdan Khmelnytsky Street, Kyiv 01054 Ukraine; Email: dmikh@ukr.net

Article info

Submitted: 05.12.2023. Revised: 24.12.2023. Accepted: 30.06.2023

References

Berg, L. S. 1922. Nomogenesis, or Evolution Based on Patterns. Gosudarstvennoe izdaniye, Peterburg, VIII, 1–306. [In Russian]

Blagoveschenski, A. V. 1925. On the orthogenetic tendencies in the process of evolution. Bulletin de l′Universitѐ de l′Asie Central (Tachkent), 10: 17–33. [In Russian]

Darwin, Ch. 1951. The Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection (Russian edition). Nauka, Moscow, Leningrad, 1–589. (Series: Darwin, Ch. Sobranie sochineniy; Vol. 3). [In Russian]

Golubovsky, M. D. 1993. Russian Biologists of Australia. Part II. S. Y. Paramonov. Priroda, 4: 92‒98. [In Russian]

Ivanov, N. N. 1926. Variation in the chemical composition of the seeds of oleiferous plants in dependence on geographical factors. Bulletin of applied botany and plant-breeding, 16: (3): 3–88. [In Russian]

Ivanov, S. L. 1926. The principal biochemical law. Bulletin of applied botany and plant-breeding, 16 (3): 89–121. [In Russian]

Karavaev, V. O. 1926. A brief outline of the development and current state of the UAS Zoological Museum. Collection of works of the Zoological Museum, 1 (1): 21–29. [In Ukrainian]

Korneev, V. O. 2014. Real life of Sergey Lesnoy (materials for the biography of the Sergei Yakovlevich Paramonov. Ukrainian Entomofaunistics, 5: 6–36. [In Ukrainian] https://sites.google.com/site/ukren_fau/

Lesnoy, S. [Paramonov, S. Y.]. 1948. The Songs of Nature. Paris, 1–63. [In Russian]

Lesnoy, S. [Paramonov, S. Y.]. 1993. ‘Academician-traveller’ P. K. Kozlov. Priroda, 3: 122–128. [In Russian]

Medyschevskaya, O. M. 1976. Theoretical Problems of Source Studies. Textbook. A. T. Nikolaeva (responsible editor). Moscow, 1–86. [In Russian]

Mikhalenok, D. K. 2023. Zoologist Volodymyr Karavaiev and the Karadag scientific station in Crimea (to the 160^th anniversary of his birth). GEO&BIO, 24: 237–269. [In Ukrainian]

Onyshchenko, O. S. (ed.). 2018. National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine — 100: Main Trends and Achievements: Documents and Materials. Book 1: 1918–1945. National V. Vernadsky Library of Ukraine, Kyiv, 1–952. (Series: Sources on the History of Science in Ukraine). [In Ukrainian]

Paramonow, S. J. 1931. Beitrӓge zur Monographie der Bombyliiden–Gattungen Amictus, Lyophlaeva etc. (Diptera). Travaux du musée zoologique, 11: 1–218. [In Ukrainian]

Paramonow, S. J. 1934. Gegenwӓrtige Systematik, ihre Metoden und Aufgaben. Travaux du musée zoologique, 13: 3–32. [In Ukrainian]

Paramonow, S. J. 1935a. Die Methoden der modernen Zoosystematik (Zoographie). Travaux du musée zoologique, 14: 3–39. [In Ukrainian]

Paramonov, S. J. 1935b. Ist das südliche Untergebiet der Palӓarktik (nach Bartenew) ӓthiopischer Herkuft. Travaux du musée zoologique, 14: 43–57. [In Ukrainian]

Paramonow, S. J. 1935c. Das Problem der Artenbildung und das Areal. Travaux du musée zoologique, 15: 5–25. [In Ukrainian]

Paramonow, S. J. 1937. Ob das System der Tiere phylogenetisch sein soll? Travaux du musée zoologique, 19: 197–212. [In Ukrainian]

Paramonow, S. J. 1939a. Modern zoological taxonomy, its theoretical and practical problems. Zoologicheskii journal, 18 (1): 7–26. [In Russian]

Paramonow, S. J. 1939b. The biosystematics needs a phylogenetical approach (A criticism of E.S. Smirnov′s views. Advances in modern biology, 10 (3): 504–514. [In Russian]

Paramonow, S. J. 1940. Es il possible construire un systѐme biologique unique pour les unitѐs taxonomiques interieures? Sovetskaia botanika, 5–6: 252–261. [In Russian]

Paramonov, S. J. 1943. Ce quiest l‘espece dans la biologie, Sovetskaia botanika, 2: 3–18. [In Russian]

Paramonov, S. Y. 1964.Evolution in biology and its essence (facts and conclusions). Renaissance (Paris), 154: 121‒125. [In Russian]

Paramonov, S. Y. 2016. Chemogenesis—a new theory of evolution. In: Shapoval, A. I. 2016. S. Y. Paramonov’s papers in the collections of National Vernadsky Library of Ukraine: Source research: scientific catalogue. L. M. Yaremenko (ed.). Kyiv, 161–227. http://irbis-nbuv gov.ua/E_LIB/EIF0000071 [In Russian]

Rochleder, F. 1854. Phytochemie. Verlag von Wilhelm Engelmann, Leipzig, VII, 1–370.

Shapoval, A. I. 2016. S. Y. Paramonov’s papers in the collections of National Vernadsky Library of Ukraine. Librarian Visnyk, 3: 33–39. [In Ukrainian] http://www.irbis-nbuv.gov.ua/everlib/item/er-0000000220

Vavilov, N. I. 1920. The Law of Homologous Series in Variation. Proceedings of the Third All-Russian Congress on Selection and Seed Production in Saratov, 4–13 June 1920. Saratov, 41–56. [In Russian]

Vernadsky, V. I. 1922. The Chemical Composition of Matter in Relation to the Chemistry of Earth’s Crust. Vremya, Petrograd, 1–48. [In Russian]

Vernadsky, V. I. 1923. The Living Matter in the Chemistry of the Sea. Nauchnoye khimiko-tekhnicheskoe izdatelstvo, Petrograd, 1–36. [In Russian]

Vernadsky, V. I. 1927. Essays on Geochemistry. Gosizdat, Moscow, 1–368. [In Russian]

Vinogradov, A. P. 1931. Chemical elemental composition of marine organisms in relation to the issues of their systematics and morphology. Priroda, 3: 230‒254. [In Russian]

Vinogradov, A. P. 1932. Geochemistry of the Living Matter. Akademia Nauk, Leningrad, 1–67. [In Russian]

Vinogradov, A. P. 1933. Chemical elemental composition of organisms and the periodic table of D. I. Mendeleev. Priroda, No. 8‒9: 28‒36. [In Russian]

Vinogradov, A. P. 1935. Chemical elemental composition of marine organisms. Trudy Biogeokhimicheskoy laboratorii, 3 (1): 63‒278. [In Russian]

Vinogradov, Y. A., Z. N. Nagorova. 1960. Metodological Guide to the Scientific and Thechnical Processing of Scientists’ Funds at the Archive of the Academy of Sciences of the USSR. Moscow, Leningrad, 1‒217. [In Russian]

Zagorodniuk, I. V. 2019. Species concepts in biology: development of ideas in Ukraine. Scientific Bulletin of the Uzhhorod University. Series Biology, 46‒47: 7‒36. [In Ukrainian]

Zhitkov, B. M. 1922. Age Variability and Evolution. Moscow, 1–70. [In Russian]